Updated Oct 31, 2026 · public sources only
Mattamy Homes reviews in Raleigh & the Triangle
Independent: no builder or agent pays us, and money never affects ratings. How we're funded
What public homeowner surveys, reviews and builder pages say about Mattamy Homes around Raleigh-Durham: our rating and how we got it, communities and prices, warranty, this month's incentives, recent comparable sales and recurring feedback themes. Every figure links to its source.
Our rating
No public homeowner-survey score found for this builder in the Triangle yet.
How this rating is computed: we show the best-sourced published homeowner-survey score, picked in a fixed order (Avid Ratings, then NewHomeSource TrustBuilder, then GuildQuality), with Raleigh-area scores preferred over company-wide ones. We do not average, adjust or weight scores, and the same rule applies to every builder. Money never affects it. Full methodology
Communities & starting prices
| Community | Town | From | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Powell | Angier | $236,900 | source |
| Vaughan Farms | Angier | $238,900 | source |
| Fox Field Farms | Broadway | $293,900 | source |
| Cardinal Landing | Coats | price not listed | source |
| Providence Creek | Fuquay-Varina | $338,900 | source |
| Bloom | Fuquay-Varina | $364,900 | source |
| Clarabella | Fuquay-Varina | $369,900 | source |
| Ashmore Townes | Garner | — | source |
| Stonebarrow | Lillington | $254,900 | source |
| Seagrass Landing | Lillington | $301,900 | source |
Warranty
1/2/10 years (workmanship / systems / structural). In-house (no third-party administrator) source
Incentives this month
None found publicly (checked Oct 31, 2026).
November 2026 incentives report
Recent comparable new-home sales
| Town | Sales | Median price | Median $/sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|
| Angier | 69 | $409,500 | $159 |
| Fuquay-Varina | 243 | $410,000 | $182 |
| Garner | 368 | $379,750 | $183 |
Wake County recorded sales since or, single-family homes built 2024 or later (all builders, not only this one); retrieved Oct 29, 2026. Wake County data
What buyers say: public feedback themes
Sales
- + Smooth buying Birdeye (Magnolia Park, Garner) Birdeye (Providence Creek, Fuquay-Varina) Reddit r/RaleighRealEstate Reddit r/raleigh
- − Deposit/payment pressure Birdeye (Magnolia Park, Garner) Birdeye (Providence Creek, Fuquay-Varina) Reddit r/RaleighRealEstate Reddit r/raleigh
- − A manager gave wrong information and broke promises made by phone. A salesperson about 3 years ago was called pushy. (Google) source
Construction
- − HVAC/electrical repeats Birdeye (Magnolia Park, Garner) Birdeye (Providence Creek, Fuquay-Varina) Reddit r/RaleighRealEstate Reddit r/raleigh
- − Moldy, damaged wood was used, and the construction lead brushed off the concern at pre-drywall. (Google) source
- + A Wendell Falls owner praises an hours-long pre-closing walkthrough with the construction manager. (Reddit) source
Warranty
- + Responsive warranty at some communities Birdeye (Magnolia Park, Garner) Birdeye (Providence Creek, Fuquay-Varina) Reddit r/RaleighRealEstate Reddit r/raleigh
- − Slow warranty Birdeye (Magnolia Park, Garner) Birdeye (Providence Creek, Fuquay-Varina) Reddit r/RaleighRealEstate Reddit r/raleigh
- − A 2020 buyer has sent 100+ emails to the warranty department about moisture problems. (Google) source
- + The same owner says two small items in the first six months were fixed promptly. (Reddit) source
Themes are summarized from public reviews and forum threads. They are individual experiences, not verified facts, and we do not quote or name reviewers.